Richard S. Van Dyke, Esq.
What is Estate Planning Legal Malpractice?
The number of lawsuits against trust, probate and estate planning attorneys has significantly increased over the last several years. Today, trust, probate and estate planing attorneys are charged with legal malpractice and breach of fiduciary duties more than any other single practice area, according to a recent survey of the largest professional liability insurers in the country.
There are several reasons driving this upsurge in claims volume. Historically, the liability of an estate planning attorney was predicated on privity between the attorney and the client. Over time, the rule of privity eroded and, in a majority of states, a third party can bring a malpractice suit against an estate planning attorney, opening the door to non-client claims by unhappy heirs or beneficiaries. Trust, probate and estate planning is also a highly technical and intricate area of the law, often with changing legal standards.
This escalation in litigation is likely to continue and increase significantly in the next few years given the current and expected enormous transfer of wealth from baby boomers to subsequent generations. However, trust, probate and estate planning attorneys can reduce their exposure to malpractice and breach of fiduciary duties by following some simple guidelines, including understanding the parameters of the attorney-client privilege, practicing safe communications, understanding relevant law, and identifying potential conflicts of interest and addressing them — a unique challenge in this practice area because of the potential for claims by non-clients.
Potentially Unethical Conduct in Relation to Charitable Giving – Red Flags
Drafting a Bequest to a Charity for Which the Attorney Serves as a Director
Drafting a Bequest to a Charity for Which the Attorney Serves on a Planned Giving Committee or Legacy Society
Representing a Client Regarding a Lifetime Gift to a Charity for Which the Attorney Serves as Director
Permitting a Charitable Organization for Which the Attorney Serves as a Director to Recommend the Attorney’s Estate Planning Services
Recommending a Charity for Which the Attorney Serves as a Director as the Object of a Bequest
Accepting Payment for a Client’s Estate Planning Services from a Charity Benefitting from the Estate Plan
Donating Estate Planning Services to a Charitable Auction
Communicating That the Attorney Will Donate a Portion of His Fees for Estate Planning Services to a Charitable Organization
Entering into an Agreement with a Charitable Organization to Charge a Reduced Fee to Members of the Organization in Consideration for a Bequest to the Organization
Offering to Provide Estate Planning Services at No Charge for a Client Who Wishes to Make a Bequest to a Charitable Organization for Which the Attorney Serves as a Director
Offering to Provide Estate Planning Services at No Charge to Members of a Charitable Organization, Such as a Synagogue, Mosque, or Church